2. Early Church period (herecies)

Before you read: Moder Christian theology is not only the product of phylosophical struggles of the Early Church and the Reformation period theologians - a big contribution to the doctrine was made by the defenders of the Apostles teachings who fought against numerous herecies that were spreading amidst Christians in 1-3AD. Read the text and find out more about these false teachings. 

Christian herecies in the Early Church (1-3 centuries)

The end of the 1st century, 2nd and 3rd centuries were pivotal times in the history of Christianity, marked by the emergence of various heresies that profoundly impacted the development of Christian theology and doctrine. These heresies challenged the orthodox beliefs of the early Church, prompting theological debates, council meetings, and the formulation of creedal statements to defend and clarify essential Christian teachings.

One of the most significant heresies of this period was Gnosticism. Gnosticism was a diverse movement characterized by the belief in hidden knowledge (gnosis) as the key to salvation. Also, it was the first big heretical movement to arise in the Early Church. Gnostics viewed the material world as inherently evil and the spiritual realm as the realm of light and perfection. This dualistic cosmology stood in stark contrast to the Christian belief in the goodness of creation and the Incarnation of Christ. Gnosticism posed a serious challenge to orthodox Christianity by offering alternative interpretations of salvation and the nature of reality.

Another notable heresy that arose in the 2nd century was Montanism. Montanism was a prophetic movement led by the self-proclaimed prophets Montanus, Priscilla, and Maximilla. The Montanists claimed to receive direct revelations from the Holy Spirit and emphasized rigorous asceticism, moral purity, and the imminence of the Second Coming of Christ. Their emphasis on ecstatic prophecies and the rejection of hierarchical authority posed a threat to the institutional Church and led to tensions within the Christian community.

Modalism is another example of a theological error within Christian doctrine that specifically pertains to the understanding of the Trinity. Modalism teaches that the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit are not distinct persons within the Godhead but rather different "modes" or manifestations of the one God. In other words, Modalism asserts that God operates in three different "modes" or roles at different times - as the Father in creation, the Son in redemption, and the Holy Spirit in sanctification - but is not three distinct persons simultaneously.

Partialism is characterized by the belief that the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit are not distinct persons within the Godhead but rather parts or components of God. In other words, it suggests that each member of the Trinity represents only a part or aspect of God's being, rather than being fully and completely God in their own right.

Docetism was yet another heresy that emerged in the 2nd century. Docetists asserted that Jesus' physical body was illusory and that He only appeared to suffer on the cross, denying the reality of His humanity and suffering. This belief conflicted with the orthodox view of the Incarnation, the crucifixion, and the redemptive significance of Jesus' sacrifice.

The early Church Fathers, such as Irenaeus, Tertullian, and Origen, played crucial roles in combating these heresies and defending orthodox Christian beliefs. Irenaeus, Bishop of Lyon, wrote extensively against Gnosticism in his work "Against Heresies," emphasizing the apostolic tradition and the unity of faith. Tertullian, a North African theologian, addressed theological controversies surrounding the nature of God, Christ, and the Trinity in his writings. Origen, an Alexandrian scholar, engaged with philosophical questions and defended the unity of God against the challenges of dualistic views.

Arianism was a significant heresy that emerged in the early Christian Church, named after its founder, Arius, a priest in Alexandria in the 4th century. Arianism denied the full divinity of Jesus Christ and challenged the orthodox belief in the consubstantiality of the Son with the Father within the Trinity. Arius taught that the Son, Jesus Christ, was a created being and not co-eternal or co-equal with God the Father. According to Arianism, there was a time when the Son did not exist, and He was the first and greatest of all God's creations. Arius and his followers emphasized the subordination of the Son to the Father, viewing Jesus as a divine being but not of the same substance as the Father. This view of Christ's nature undermined His role as the divine Son of God and Savior.

In response to these heresies, the early Church convened councils and synods to address doctrinal controversies and establish orthodox theological positions. The First Council of Nicaea in 325 AD, for example, was called to address the Arian controversy, which challenged the divinity of Christ. The Nicene Creed, formulated at this council, affirmed the full divinity of Christ and became a foundational statement of faith for the Church.

Overall, the heresies of the 2nd and 3rd centuries played a crucial role in shaping the development of Christian theology, doctrine, and ecclesiology. These theological controversies spurred the Church to define its beliefs more precisely, articulate fundamental doctrines, and safeguard the faith from erroneous teachings. The struggles against heresies ultimately contributed to the consolidation of orthodox Christian tradition and the formulation of core theological principles that continue to guide the Church to this day.

___________________________________________________________________________________

Task 1: Explain the terms in bold. 

Task 2: Match the analogue used to explain the doctrine of the Trinity and a corresponding heretical teaching:

1. MODALISM                a). The Trinity = The Sun (God), the light (Son), the heat (Holy Spirit)

2. ARIANISM                  b). The Trinity = three different forms of water

3. PARTIALISM             c). The Trinity = three leaves of a shamrock

Task 3: Answer the following questions

1. What heretical teaching was the earliest to appear in the Early Church?

2. What is the main idea of Montanism?

3. What is the difference between Modalism and Partialism?

4. Who was Arius? What was the main point of his theology? 

5. Name theologians who fought against the Early Church herecies

6. When as the Nicene Creed introduced? What did it mean to the Christian doctrine at the time?